I bought in my true size 8. The toe does not pinch and the heel conforms to my foot without rubbing. I did buy leather conditioner at suggestion of the salesperson. I rubbed it in on the lower part of my boot, not the shaft. Then when they were slightly damp from the leather conditioner, I put them on and wore them around the house for an hour while they dried. Then rebuffed them with a microfiber towel. The leather was soft enough that they conformed to my feet. This is genuine leather and they are a sturdy boot. And the leather smells so good! There is some padding in the heel, but wish it was a bit more. I am going to Nashville and wanted a pair of boots for the trip. So glad that I bought these and then wore them around as they conformed to my feet. Great boot!!